« From Russia with... | Main | Interrogation Video »

Death Penalty Stays

Tom Goldstein at SCOTUSblog has this post correcting a mistaken New York Times story regarding stays of execution and the "rule of four." It only takes four votes for the Supreme Court to accept a case to be reviewed (grant certiorari), but it takes a majority of five to grant a stay. Traditionally, a fifth Justice has added the necessary vote to grant the stay when a case has been accepted for review. There has been no exception to this practice in a long time, but the Times article mistakenly equates four votes to grant a stay with four votes to grant certiorari. Tom notes they are not the same and that Chief Justice Roberts' confirmation hearing testimony involved the latter.

Post a comment

If you return to this page after signing in, click here for instructions.

This is a place for informed discussion of issues related to criminal law and criminal justice policy. Persons who wish to engage in ad hominem attacks, name-calling, profanity, flame wars, and general rudeness are cordially invited to do so somewhere else. For this reason, and to prevent comment spam, commenters are required to register with TypeKey, and individual comments will have to be approved before they are published for your first few comments.