<< Another Unauthorized Filing? | Main | "He sat in a room, and he lied to me" >>


Texas Execution

| 0 Comments
AP reports:

The U.S. Supreme Court denied the last-chance appeal of a former gang member scheduled for execution Tuesday evening after his defense attorneys argued that the man, who was convicted of killing three rivals 14 years ago in San Antonio, is mentally impaired.
The court denied a stay for Miguel Paredes in a brief order released Tuesday. Paredes, 32, was convicted along with two other men in the September 2000 shooting deaths of three people with ties to the Mexican Mafia. The victims' bodies were rolled up in a carpet, driven about 50 miles southwest, dumped and set on fire. A farmer investigating a grass fire found the remains.
*                                          *                                      *
Paredes' attorney, David Dow, said the execution should be stopped because Paredes had "a significant mental disease" that may have affected his judgment when he told his previous lawyer 10 years ago not to investigate his family background. Dow also told the Supreme Court that Paredes' previous lawyer was deficient for not investigating the inmate's medical history.

In a response filed Tuesday morning, state lawyers said Paredes "presented no evidence that he is or ever has been mentally ill or incompetent," and that his earlier attorney couldn't be considered deficient when he "abided by Paredes' explicit instructions." Lower courts have sided with the state, which also noted that the latest appeal was filed after a deadline.
Unfortunately, the news story does not say what this "significant mental disease" is.  Update:  The Fifth Circuit's opinion indicates it is Dysthymic Disorder, which is kind of junior varsity depression.  Sorry, that is nowhere near severe enough to warrant reopening proceedings at this late stage.

Justice Breyer was recused from the case.  No dissent is noted.

Update 2:  Michael Graczyk reports for AP that the execution has been completed.

Leave a comment

Monthly Archives