<< News Scan | Main | Where Is Sentencing Reform Today? >>


The Senate

| 9 Comments
8:30 PST:  Republicans are now projected to hold at least 52 Senate seats in the next Congress.   Party control is not everything, but overall the next Congress should be better for the cause of justice. 

9 Comments

When the GOP takes control, not a single solitary Obama judge.

There are enough 'rats on the federal bench.

I wouldn't go that far, but hopefully Senate control will have a moderating effect on the judges President Obama chooses to nominate. We saw that effect in the Clinton Administration.

Much depends on two things: First, whether Obama goes ahead by executive order with a big immigration non-deportation; and second, whether he uses the lame duck session to push nominees he knows would not get through in the new Congress.

If he does those things, the Republicans will justifiably look on him as provocative and confrontational, and will hand it right back when they get the reins in January. They are unlikely to trade in victory for subservience.

Decencyevolves: A tiny silver lining for people who share my point of view: Governors Malloy and Hickenlooper both narrowly survived the Republican wave. Even in a year like this, the politics surrounding criminal justice issues have changed since 1988 and 1990, when Governor Dukakis and Kathleen Brown both suffered defeats attributed in no small part to their views on the death penalty.

Decencyevolves, you lack a sense of proportion. I get it--he supports the death penalty, so he's A-ok in your book. However, John Hickenlooper is a profoundly evil man who shouldn't be anywhere near public office. It's one thing to oppose the death penalty. It's another thing to run on a platform of death penalty support and grant indefinite reprieves. It's still another thing drag out a reprieve process that is surpassing narcissistic. Then, it's still another thing to drag out such a process only to belch out some juvenile nonsense justifying a decision to grant a quadruple killer an indefinite reprieve. If all of this were in a vacuum, it would be worthy of ridicule, but not much else.

But Hickenlooper pulled all of this in the context of four murder victims' families who, it must be stressed, didn't ask to be relatives of a murder victim, nor did the surviving victim. Imagine, for a second, being one of those people--waiting patiently for justice to be done. It would be one thing to have the rug yanked out from under you---quite another to be forced to witness Hickenlooper's narcissistic ... display of faux hand-wringing. The hell he put those people though--and for what, to help out a capital murderer?

Repulsive is too mild a word, and you "decency" evolves let out a huzzah for this moral pygmy. Either you're ignorant, in which case, you shouldn't be taken seriously, or you're just good with all of this. Which is it?

[This comment has been edited slightly -- KS]

For an incumbent governor to have the majority of votes cast to throw him out is hardly anything to crow about. Yes, Hickenlooper won another term, but he won by a whisker in a race that nearly all political observers expected to be a cakewalk not too long ago.

It isn't surprising the Republicans retook the Senate - they had a favorable map and deeply unpopular Obama. And, the democrats had some campaign missteps in Colorado / Iowa similar to what happened to Republican candidates in 2012 in Missouri and Indiana.

As to the implications, it is hard to say - probably see some moderation on nominations and some sort of compromise of budgetary issues, but beyond that I doubt much will change.

Two of Obama's Justices signed off on the appalling Plata decision which continues to get real people hurt. Had persons of sense been appointed, there are people who would not have suffered the awful experience of being a violent crime victim. That, in my mind, means he shouldn't be trusted with a single nominee to the federal bench.

Interesting how "decency"evolves doesn't have a lot to say in defense in Hickenlooper. I think he (or she) took an opportunity to gloat and has turned tail and run.

Leave a comment

Monthly Archives