<< News Scan | Main | Cruz for President >>


Federal Prosecutors Warn State Judges How They Must Behave

| 0 Comments
Under the federal Constitution, governmental power is disbursed by creating federal and state jurisdictions, and by establishing, within federal jurisdiction, separate and co-equal branches.

Someone might want to remind the current Justice Department of this fact, in light of yesterday's New York Times story, "Justice Department Condemns Profit-Minded Court Policies Targeting the Poor."  The gist of it is that DOJ has snarled at state judges for attempting to collect fines lawbreakers owe.  Such efforts, we are informed, violate civil rights.

I had not previously been aware that there was a "civil right" to be a scofflaw, but you learn something new every day from the Obama Justice Department.  Perhaps the right to skip out on paying traffic fines is part, as the NYT puts it, of the Administration's push for the "rights"  --  ready now  --   of "the poor and the disabled, the transgender [sic] and the homeless."



I thought these two paragraphs from the article were wonderfully ironic (emphasis added):

"This unconstitutional practice is often framed as a routine administrative matter," [Assistant Attorney General] Gupta wrote. "For example, a motorist who is arrested for driving with a suspended license may be told that the penalty for the citation is $300 and that a court date will be scheduled only upon the completion of a $300 payment."

The letter echoes the conclusions of the Justice Department's investigation of the Police Department and court in Ferguson, Mo. Investigators there concluded that the court was a moneymaking venture, not an independent branch of government. 

There are those of us who thought the states, including state courts, were also independent of the feds, and DOJ in particular, cf. Medellin v. Texas.   Well, that was then.  Erstwhile fans of federalism  --  those who wonder why the feds bother with pot, for example, and what their legal basis is for doing so  -- might have some problems figuring out what business the feds have menacing state court judges about traffic fines.  I have a feeling, though, that the key word there is "erstwhile." 

Leave a comment

Monthly Archives