<< Three Strikes and You Go Back, Jack, Do It Again | Main | Commenter Registration >>


News Scan

| 5 Comments
Deincarceration California Style:  As has been noted many times on this blog, most serious and violent crimes are committed by repeat offenders.  Since the mid-1990s, a proven formula for reducing crime was adopted both locally and nationally with great success.  The ingredients were targeted proactive policing and progressive sentencing.   Over the past decade, in response to claims by academics, activists, and liberal politicians that these policies targeted minorities and condemned otherwise upstanding citizens to decades in prison for minor offenses, several big cities and some states adopted reforms backing off policing and reducing sentences for habitual criminals.  California has been a leader in this movement, adopting four major sentencing reduction laws and numerous local policies limiting policing over the past eight years.  The most recent of these is Proposition 57, adopted in 2016 after a multi-million dollar publicity campaign convinced voters that it would only allow for early parole for well-behaved inmates convicted of non-violent crimes.  Almost immediately, district attorneys reported that a car thief, wife beater, or drug dealer eligible for early parole under this law could have prior convictions for rape or even murder.  Governor Brown, who helped finance the initiative along with George Soros, claimed that this was flat wrong.  Last week, NBC Los Angeles reported that the Governor was the one who was flat wrong, noting that numerous inmates with priors for crimes like murder and violent assault have been granted parole under Proposition 57.  Prosecutor Michele Hanisee, President of the Association of Deputy District Attorneys (ADDA) for Los Angeles, told reporters that the public was duped by the proposition's supporters.  "It's very clear they intended to release violent offenders by re-describing them, despite their crimes, as nonviolent offenders."   Both the news story and the ADDA blog cite examples of the kinds of criminals now considered non-violent and eligible for early parole.

    

5 Comments

The Casillas parole decision acknowledged the history of violence.

"However, the passage of time coupled with the lack of violent behavior over the last 22 years diminishes the prejudicial impact of the prior convictions. Thus, the inmate’s prior criminal history is a mitigating factor for the reasons discussed above," an official wrote.

So much for giving the full story.

The point of the post is that inmates convicted of crimes of violence are eligible for Proposition 57 early release despite the promises of the proponents of that initiative to the contrary.

The quote in your comment is not relevant to that point, so omission of it was entirely appropriate.

If the proponents had said to the public that inmates with long-ago records of violent crime should be eligible for consideration, that would be a different matter. That is not what they said.

The proposition clearly stated that those convicted of non violent crimes would be eligible for early parole. Its shocking that you of all people, who argued that an explicit promise of a five year time limit in a proposition was actually meaningless and yet not a fraud on the voters, are criticizing a proposition for doing exactly what the words of the proposition said it would do.

I did not argue that, regardless of what you may have read.

"The proposition clearly stated that those convicted of non violent crimes would be eligible for early parole." So leaving out that a drug dealer is eligible for early parole even with priors for murder and aggravated assault is adequate disclosure? Is this person a violent criminal or not? I should add that when the Fresno Police Chief went public about this, the Governor said it was not true. What's shocking is that anyone would think that lying about what Proposition 57 would actually do is defensible, especially when the lives and safety of innocent people are at stake.

Leave a comment

Monthly Archives