PA Supreme Court Hears Death Penalty Challenge: The Pennsylvania Supreme Court is considering a petition by two murderers on the state's death row to abolish the death penalty for its disproportionate impact on poor black defendants. The Associated Press reports that attorneys representing murderers Jermont Cox and Kevin Marinelli are encouraging the court to convert the sentences of the state's 137 condemned murderers to life in prison. Cox, a low level drug dealer, was convicted of murdering two men in 1992. Marinelli was convicted of the 1994 murder of man in Kulpmont, PA during the burglary of his home. The Washington Times reports that Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner,who opposes the death penalty, is a driving force behind the court challenge. Krasner told reporters that 82% of Philly's death row inmates are black, while statewide, blacks make up about half the inmates on death row. Left unanswered is whether blacks disproportionately commit aggravated murder. If most aggravated murderers in the state are black, it is not surprising that most murderers sentenced to death will be of the same race.
<< A Watershed Right to the Insanity Defense | Main | Playing the Race Card Yet Again on the Death Penalty >>
1 Comment
Leave a comment
Search

Recent Entries
- Crime and Consequences Has Moved
- Abolish the Police?
- News Scan
- Cal. Law on Mandatory Reporting of Kiddie Porn May (or May Not) Be Unconstitutional
- USCA9 Upholds Sentence of Serial Murderer/Rapist Dean Carter
- News Scan
- Robocalls
- Venue at 30,000 Feet
- News Scan
- Supreme Court Takes Excessive Force/Seizure Case
Monthly Archives
- January 2020 (1)
- December 2019 (25)
- November 2019 (35)
- October 2019 (27)
- September 2019 (26)
- August 2019 (22)
- July 2019 (29)
- June 2019 (26)
- May 2019 (36)
- April 2019 (33)
- March 2019 (31)
- February 2019 (21)
- January 2019 (28)
- December 2018 (19)
- November 2018 (17)
- October 2018 (44)
- September 2018 (45)
- August 2018 (34)
- July 2018 (33)
- June 2018 (52)
- May 2018 (34)
- April 2018 (45)
- March 2018 (39)
- February 2018 (56)
- January 2018 (50)
- December 2017 (50)
- November 2017 (43)
- October 2017 (60)
- September 2017 (53)
- August 2017 (46)
- July 2017 (41)
- June 2017 (86)
- May 2017 (87)
- April 2017 (68)
- March 2017 (57)
- February 2017 (66)
- January 2017 (52)
- December 2016 (57)
- November 2016 (79)
- October 2016 (66)
- September 2016 (60)
- August 2016 (72)
- July 2016 (120)
- June 2016 (93)
- May 2016 (80)
- April 2016 (68)
- March 2016 (78)
- February 2016 (80)
- January 2016 (82)
- December 2015 (72)
- November 2015 (63)
- October 2015 (100)
- September 2015 (81)
- August 2015 (76)
- July 2015 (78)
- June 2015 (88)
- May 2015 (110)
- April 2015 (95)
- March 2015 (92)
- February 2015 (65)
- January 2015 (78)
- December 2014 (126)
- November 2014 (72)
- October 2014 (95)
- September 2014 (85)
- August 2014 (92)
- July 2014 (81)
- June 2014 (73)
- May 2014 (104)
- April 2014 (96)
- March 2014 (62)
- February 2014 (70)
- January 2014 (66)
- December 2013 (57)
- November 2013 (68)
- October 2013 (67)
- September 2013 (57)
- August 2013 (90)
- July 2013 (54)
- June 2013 (65)
- May 2013 (103)
- April 2013 (135)
- March 2013 (84)
- February 2013 (79)
- January 2013 (81)
- December 2012 (96)
- November 2012 (65)
- October 2012 (110)
- September 2012 (74)
- August 2012 (95)
- July 2012 (70)
- June 2012 (80)
- May 2012 (86)
- April 2012 (84)
- March 2012 (78)
- February 2012 (58)
- January 2012 (63)
- December 2011 (42)
- November 2011 (73)
- October 2011 (108)
- September 2011 (98)
- August 2011 (95)
- July 2011 (84)
- June 2011 (90)
- May 2011 (125)
- April 2011 (90)
- March 2011 (123)
- February 2011 (96)
- January 2011 (102)
- December 2010 (106)
- November 2010 (88)
- October 2010 (102)
- September 2010 (107)
- August 2010 (83)
- July 2010 (78)
- June 2010 (96)
- May 2010 (102)
- April 2010 (108)
- March 2010 (105)
- February 2010 (100)
- January 2010 (113)
- December 2009 (58)
- November 2009 (72)
- October 2009 (89)
- September 2009 (85)
- August 2009 (62)
- July 2009 (61)
- June 2009 (72)
- May 2009 (65)
- April 2009 (60)
- March 2009 (90)
- February 2009 (56)
- January 2009 (57)
- December 2008 (71)
- November 2008 (62)
- October 2008 (74)
- September 2008 (52)
- August 2008 (33)
- July 2008 (56)
- June 2008 (71)
- May 2008 (54)
- April 2008 (83)
- March 2008 (51)
- February 2008 (40)
- January 2008 (40)
- December 2007 (34)
- November 2007 (41)
- October 2007 (45)
- September 2007 (47)
- August 2007 (42)
- July 2007 (49)
- June 2007 (61)
- May 2007 (55)
- April 2007 (55)
- March 2007 (55)
- February 2007 (57)
- January 2007 (51)
- December 2006 (30)
- November 2006 (46)
- October 2006 (52)
- September 2006 (30)
- August 2006 (44)
- July 2006 (34)
- June 2006 (26)
- May 2006 (14)
- April 2006 (1)
About C & C Blog
About CJLF
Issues
- Academia (96)
- Appeal (3)
- Blog (37)
- Cases (130)
- Civil Suits (75)
- Clemency (49)
- Collateral Consequences (9)
- Congress (3)
- Constitution (103)
- Counsel (173)
- Criminal Procedure (194)
- Death Penalty (1918)
- Drugs (223)
- Equal Protection (11)
- Evidence (246)
- Federal Courts (133)
- Federalism (45)
- Firearms (49)
- First Amendment (105)
- Forfeiture (7)
- General (989)
- Habeas Corpus (469)
- Humor (129)
- Immigration (92)
- International (171)
- Journalism (33)
- Judicial Selection (165)
- Judiciary (14)
- Jury Trial (30)
- Juveniles (119)
- Mental State (290)
- Military (3)
- National Security (20)
- News Scan (2434)
- Notorious Cases (493)
- Off Topic (51)
- Policing (216)
- Policy (7)
- Politics (688)
- Polls (80)
- Prisons (299)
- Probation and Parole (72)
- Public Order (73)
- Rehabilitation (34)
- Schools (6)
- Search and Seizure (211)
- Self-defense (14)
- Sentencing (837)
- Sex offenses (60)
- Social Factors (177)
- State Courts (77)
- Studies (360)
- Stupid Crooks (7)
- Terrorism (301)
- U.S. Supreme Court (1692)
- USDoJ (102)
- Use of Force (45)
- Victims' Rights (57)
Links
Blogs
SCOTUSblog
Bench Memos (NRO)
The Volokh Conspiracy
Sentencing Law & Policy
Homicide Survivors
FedSoc Blog
The Cert Pool
Bench Memos (NRO)
The Volokh Conspiracy
Sentencing Law & Policy
Homicide Survivors
FedSoc Blog
The Cert Pool
There is a prosecutorial and judicial approach to the death penalty, an attitude, a choix de vie if you will, which, when present, seems to work so smoothly.
In the case of Donald Hugh Davidson, the murderer of Rosie Welsh and rapist plead guilty to avoid the death penalty, yet received-it-nonetheless simply
because:“The court concludes the appropriate sentence is death.”
Having previously committed a “molestation of someone younger than 12” and “aggravated battery on a pregnant woman,” this sex offender more recently: attempted to rape a mother beloved by “everybody that met her,” then
“strangled and stabbed her” to death; later repeatedly sexually
battering her daughter, a victim younger than 12, i.e.:
“sexually battered her in the home before kidnapping her in the family van,
[which he stole] the State Attorney’s Office said. He took her to several
areas in Clay County and performed other sexual acts on her.”
https://www.jacksonville.com/news/20190918/middleburg-sex-predator-
sentenced-to-death-in-2014-slaying-of-woman-and-rape-of-daughter
[ Praises to the LE of Clay County, State Atty. Melissa Nelson, and Circuit Judge
Don H. Lester. May Rosie Welsh’s family know peace in the midst of chaos.]